What kind of criticism would prompt a major publisher to withdraw from circulation a New York Times bestseller by a recognized scholar? One would think the objections would have to be weighty and the critics unquestioned experts in the particular field. In the case of The Jefferson Lies, one would be mistaken to make those assumptions.
In 2012, David Barton’s popular analysis of Thomas Jefferson was pulled by the book’s publisher, Thomas Nelson, based on what appears to have been an academic putsch designed to protect the now popular view of the third president as a secular deist and hypocritical slave-holding philanderer. This uprising was led by a motley intellectual crew who, for the most part, had little or no expertise in the subject matter at issue.
The re-release of The Jefferson Lies by WND Books begins with an extended preface in which the author discusses the largely picayune objections raised against his original work – primarily by a psychology professor from Grove City College, Warren Throckmorton. These somewhat arcane refutations should have been placed at the end of the work – allowing Barton’s clear and convincing evidence to speak first for itself. That evidence primarily concerns “lies” about Jefferson’s relationship with his slave, Sally Hemings, “lies” about Jefferson’s supposed hypocrisy vis-à-vis slavery, “lies” about the ex-president’s position concerning the separation of church and state, and “lies” related to Jefferson’s religious beliefs.
Barton’s most startling revelation concerns the brazenly dishonest claim that DNA evidence proved that Jefferson fathered one of Sally Hemings’s children. This blockbuster story in Nature magazine (November 5, 1998) was splashed with gusto all over the national media. The retraction of this “proof” came eight weeks later – with all the impact of an obscure page 16 correction. Equally significant was the political end to which the initial DNA lie was employed, coming as it did in the midst
Read more: http://www.americanthinker.com/articles/2016/04/exposing_the_myths_youve_always_believed_about_thomas_jefferson.html#ixzz44foDHYG1
Follow us: @AmericanThinker on Twitter | AmericanThinker on Facebook
You must be logged in to reply to this topic.